6.7Another Man's Poison
Movie, 1951


MovieR1 h 31 minDrama, Thriller
6.1/ 10 TMDB user score from 446 votes
“Wanting her was his first mistake.”
A guy gets more than he bargained for after entering into an affair with the wife of an investment banker. Soon, a suspicious death and substantial life insurance policy embroil him in a scandal.
Streaming data provided by JustWatch, via TMDB.
Streaming verdict for United States
Stream it on Philo or Starz Amazon Channel
In the United States, Careful What You Wish For is included with Philo, Starz Amazon Channel, Lionsgate+ Amazon Channel and 3 more, so subscribers can start it at no extra cost. Without a subscription, it's also free with ads on The CW, Fandango at Home Free, or Tubi TV. At 1 h 31 min, it's an easy one-evening watch.
Availability checked on

Philo
Included in subscription

Starz Amazon Channel
Included in subscription

Lionsgate+ Amazon Channel
Included in subscription

Starz
Included in subscription

Starz Apple TV channel
Included in subscription

Starz Roku Premium Channel
Included in subscription

The CW
Free with ads

Fandango at Home Free
Free with ads

Free with ads

Kanopy
Free

Hoopla
Free

Fawesome
Free

Amazon Video
Digital rental

Apple TV Store
Digital rental

Google Play Movies
Digital rental

YouTube
Digital rental

Fandango At Home
Digital rental

Amazon Video
Digital purchase

Apple TV Store
Digital purchase

Google Play Movies
Digital purchase

YouTube
Digital purchase

Fandango At Home
Digital purchase
| Service | How you watch | Keeps access | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Philo | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Philo (opens in a new tab) |
Starz Amazon Channel | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Starz Amazon Channel (opens in a new tab) |
Lionsgate+ Amazon Channel | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Lionsgate+ Amazon Channel (opens in a new tab) |
Starz | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Starz (opens in a new tab) |
Starz Apple TV channel | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Starz Apple TV channel (opens in a new tab) |
Starz Roku Premium Channel | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Starz Roku Premium Channel (opens in a new tab) |
The CW | Free with ads | While it stays in the catalogue | Open The CW (opens in a new tab) |
Fandango at Home Free | Free with ads | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Fandango at Home Free (opens in a new tab) |
Tubi TV | Free with ads | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Tubi TV (opens in a new tab) |
Kanopy | Free | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Kanopy (opens in a new tab) |
Hoopla | Free | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Hoopla (opens in a new tab) |
Fawesome | Free | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Fawesome (opens in a new tab) |
Amazon Video | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Amazon Video (opens in a new tab) |
Apple TV Store | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Apple TV Store (opens in a new tab) |
Google Play Movies | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Google Play Movies (opens in a new tab) |
YouTube | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open YouTube (opens in a new tab) |
Fandango At Home | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Fandango At Home (opens in a new tab) |
Amazon Video | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open Amazon Video (opens in a new tab) |
Apple TV Store | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open Apple TV Store (opens in a new tab) |
Google Play Movies | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open Google Play Movies (opens in a new tab) |
YouTube | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open YouTube (opens in a new tab) |
Fandango At Home | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open Fandango At Home (opens in a new tab) |
Streaming verdict for United Kingdom
Not available in UK
Careful What You Wish For isn't listed on any streaming, rental or purchase service in the United Kingdom right now. For comparison, it's included with Philo, Starz Amazon Channel and 4 more in the United States and Beamafilm in Australia.
Availability checked on
No service lists Careful What You Wish For in United Kingdom today. We recheck every day; the other countries above may have options.
Streaming verdict for Canada
Watch free with ads on Tubi TV or Plex
Careful What You Wish For costs nothing to watch in Canada: Tubi TV and Plex stream it free with ads. For an ad-free copy, rent it from CosmoGo or YouTube. For comparison, it's included with Philo, Starz Amazon Channel and 4 more in the United States and Beamafilm in Australia. At 1 h 31 min, it's an easy one-evening watch.
Availability checked on

Free with ads

Plex
Free with ads

CosmoGo
Digital rental

YouTube
Digital rental

CosmoGo
Digital purchase

YouTube
Digital purchase
| Service | How you watch | Keeps access | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Tubi TV | Free with ads | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Tubi TV (opens in a new tab) |
Plex | Free with ads | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Plex (opens in a new tab) |
CosmoGo | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open CosmoGo (opens in a new tab) |
YouTube | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open YouTube (opens in a new tab) |
CosmoGo | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open CosmoGo (opens in a new tab) |
YouTube | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open YouTube (opens in a new tab) |
Streaming verdict for Australia
Stream it on Beamafilm
In Australia, Careful What You Wish For is included with Beamafilm, so subscribers can start it at no extra cost. Without a subscription, it's also free with ads on Beamafilm. At 1 h 31 min, it's an easy one-evening watch.
Availability checked on

Beamafilm
Included in subscription

Beamafilm
Free

Apple TV Store
Digital rental

YouTube
Digital rental

Fetch TV
Digital rental

Beamafilm
Digital rental

Apple TV Store
Digital purchase

YouTube
Digital purchase

Fetch TV
Digital purchase
| Service | How you watch | Keeps access | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Beamafilm | Included in subscription | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Beamafilm (opens in a new tab) |
Beamafilm | Free | While it stays in the catalogue | Open Beamafilm (opens in a new tab) |
Apple TV Store | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Apple TV Store (opens in a new tab) |
YouTube | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open YouTube (opens in a new tab) |
Fetch TV | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Fetch TV (opens in a new tab) |
Beamafilm | Digital rental | For the rental window | Open Beamafilm (opens in a new tab) |
Apple TV Store | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open Apple TV Store (opens in a new tab) |
YouTube | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open YouTube (opens in a new tab) |
Fetch TV | Digital purchase | Yes, in your library | Open Fetch TV (opens in a new tab) |
Nick JonasDoug Martin
Isabel LucasLena Harper
Dermot MulroneyEliott Harper
Kandyse McClureAngie Alvarez
Graham RogersCarson
Marc MacaulayGordon
David SherrillBrian Martin
Kevin J. O'ConnorPier/Patron du bar
Paul SorvinoSheriff Big Jack
Alex ter AvestEmma Shalloway
John Driskell HopkinsGus
Ross GalloLena's LawyerIn the US it's included with Philo, Starz Amazon Channel, and Lionsgate+ Amazon Channel; in Canada it's free with ads on Tubi TV and Plex; in Australia it's included with Beamafilm. Availability changes often; the table on this page shows every option per country.
Yes, legally: in the US on The CW and Fandango at Home Free; in Canada on Tubi TV and Plex; in Australia on Beamafilm. These services are free because they show ads.
No. Careful What You Wish For isn't on Netflix in the US, UK, Canada or Australia at the moment.
Careful What You Wish For runs 1 h 31 min (91 minutes).
Careful What You Wish For is rated R in the US (MPA) and 15 in the UK (BBFC).
Careful What You Wish For was directed by Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum and stars Nick Jonas, Isabel Lucas, and Dermot Mulroney.
Titles that people who rated Careful What You Wish For on TMDB also rated well. Open one to check where it streams in your country.
6.7Movie, 1951
5.8Movie, 2022
6.8Movie, 1994
6.0Movie, 2020
6.1Movie, 2006
6.8Movie, 2023
6.7Movie, 2023
6.5Movie, 2007
6.4Movie, 2014
7.5Movie, 1967
7.9Movie, 2014
6.7Movie, 1984